BREAK IN TRANSCRIPT
O`DONNELL: Joining our discussion now is Democratic Senator Cory Booker of
New Jersey. He`s a member of that Senate Judiciary Committee.
Senator, thank you very much for joining us tonight.
It`s so ironic to hear Senator Cornyn talk about something being developed
behind closed doors.
Correct me if I`m wrong, but isn`t that the way the Republican legislation
was developed?
BOOKER: Incredibly so, behind closed doors. That`s the way they operate.
You remember that toxic Trump tax plan was done behind closed doors, not
through normal process.
So to get lectured by them about this being something that they are
sincerely trying to do, to me is outrageous, because I`ve seen this from
the criminal justice reform legislation we passed to how immigration reform
was done in the years before I came to the Senate. When they`re serious
about something, they`ll put it through a committee or create a gang of
eight or gang of ten, you`ve heard of these before.
There`s no desire to get something substantive done. They`re pushing a bill
on the floor that does not answer the demands of so many of the people out
there on the streets that want to see an end to the killing of unarmed
black people, because let me just be clear, it would not have stopped the
awful practice, like our bill does, that got Breonna Taylor killed in her
bed. It would not have stopped the awful chokehold that our bill bans that
got Eric Garner killed. It would not allow George Floyd`s family to hold
those officers accountable in federal court through civil rights claims.
These are all things they don`t address. Our bill does. And it`s just so
frustrating that they`re setting up process to fail so they can turn the
page and not rise to this moment in history.
O`DONNELL: Senator McConnell is saying just let us put the Republican bill
on the floor. You have enough votes to block them procedurally from getting
the Republican bill on the floor. He`s saying let us put the Republican
bill on the floor, and then it`s open to amendments. You can bring in the
Booker/Harris amendment to ban chokeholds by American police officers, and
then it`s up to a vote in the Senate, and 51 votes, it will go into the
bill.
What`s wrong with that approach?
BOOKER: Well, every major civil rights organization agrees with us, over
130 organizations signed on to a letter that this is a plan set up to fail,
because what Mitch McConnell has -- said he would do is in the Senate he
would make a 60-vote threshold for everything. That means we would need to
get 14 senators to defect and do chokehold legislation, to defect to end
racial and religious profiling, to defect to stop military equipment to be
given to police departments.
And he knows he can stop those amendments from passing one by one by one by
one. And so, it`s not a serious offer. He set the system up to fail. And
getting on this bill, letting him go through these processes, to me, would
be an exercise in futility when he`s preordained the result.
So what we`re asking for is just simply to allow us to come together,
because there are Republicans that have already -- one has introduced
legislation on qualified immunity. I`m having conversations with other ones
about other things. I think if we sat down and started working on this, the
way we`ve done other things, we could come up with a bill that honors the
moment and actually creates real accountability in American policing.
O`DONNELL: Yeah. I mean, him imposing a 60-vote -- asking for an agreement
of a 60-vote threshold for amendments does make amendments impossible. It
doesn`t seem like that long ago, but I guess it was, Senator, when I was
working in the Senate and it took exactly 51 votes to get your amendments
onto a bill.
So what about this other procedural possibility? Letting the Republican
bill go to the floor with a 60-vote threshold, absolutely you won`t get any
amendments on that bill. But then it just goes into conference with the
bill from the House of Representatives, what Nancy Pelosi and the House
Democrat`s bill, and from that, either something comes out the Democrats
vote for or it doesn`t.
Why not leave that negotiation to what is the conference committee that
could produce a bill that both bodies could vote on?
BOOKER: Yes, well, that`s the point. If it went into the Senate, we would
have to vote it out. So he would have to get 60 votes to go to conference.
And that`s the absurdity of what he`s proposing. First of all, you`re not
going to get Democrats in good faith to vote for a bill that doesn`t
address any of the issues that are core and purposeful to us.
But you don`t have to go to conference. I`ve watched in the Senate in the
short six years I`ve been here so many in what they call four corners
negotiation. We did it on criminal justice reform. We have the White House
at the table.
We had members on the Republican and Democrat side of the Senate. We had
house members at the table. We all got together and hammered out, because
we all desire to get something done. So this idea that you have to go to a
conference and have a negotiation is just wrong. I can tell you confidently
that Nadler, the Head of this Congressional Black Caucus Karen Bass they
would love to get into a room everybody and start to negotiate what real
reform would look like. We do not need to go through these processes that
Mitch McConnell is establishing to get into a room for negotiation.
In fact, I don`t think I can remember a time when Democrats have pleaded
this much to please sit down in a room and negotiate with us. What Mitch
McConnell clearly wants to do is to turn a page and be able to point a
finger of blame at Democrats is opposed to accepting responsibility for
what is really needed right now, which is not partisanship.
It`s to address generational long - generations long problems, that even
king, when he stood on the march in Washington and people forget in his I
have a dream speech. He specifically called out police brutality. From that
to the Kerner report to the 21st Century Task Force and Policing. I can`t
tell you how many times this country has studied it held commissions on it,
done reports on it, all the things Republicans are calling for in their
bill yet again.
People are not marching in the streets saying we want a commission. They
are not marching the street saying we want more data. They are marching the
street they say they want to stop police from choking them to death. They
want to stop being profiled based upon their race. They want to end no-
knock warrants. They want have transparency in the police departments. And
if a cop or a police officer does wrong, they want to make sure that
federal authorities can prosecute them and either they won`t have
impossible standards to reach. This is not that complicated, we can get
this done if we sit together and have a real conversation about what will
save black lives in this country.
LAWRENCE O`DONNELL, MSNBC HOST: Senator Cory Booker, thank you very much
for joining us tonight. We really appreciate it.
BOOKER: Thank you very much. Thank you.
BREAK IN TRANSCRIPT